Skip to content
Book condition grader · updated November 2026

Used book condition grader & listing description generator

Misgrading is how a clean $12 book becomes a return dispute. A light spine crease, a remainder mark, foxing on the page edges or a torn dust jacket can move a book from Like New to Good — and Amazon and eBay do not always agree on where it lands.

Run the physical checklist, get a separate Amazon and eBay grade, and copy a ready-to-paste flaw disclosure. Every selected defect is written into the listing so the buyer knows exactly what is arriving.

Amazon + eBay rulesSpine · cover · pagesFoxing · remainder marks · jacketsAmazon book conditions

How to use this calculator

Three steps to a reliable answer.

Quick guide
  1. 1Choose the format and rate the spine, cover, pages, markings and dust jacket.
  2. 2Add ex-library, remainder marks, missing pages or inserts, odor and any unique flaw.
  3. 3Compare the Amazon and eBay grades, then copy the generated condition note or description.

Amazon and eBay grade the same flaw differently. This tool caps boundary flaws one level lower than the marketplace minimum to reduce return risk, and writes every disclosed flaw into the listing text.

Book details

Grade the physical copy, not the title.

A missing or torn jacket changes the Amazon and eBay grades differently.

Boundary flaws are graded down one level to reduce return risk. Amazon and eBay rules differ, so compare both grades before listing.

Amazon grade

Used - Like New

Used - Like New

No grade-lowering flaws selected.

eBay grade

Like New

Like New

No grade-lowering flaws selected.

Copy-ready listing text

Amazon condition note · 500 character limit

Used - Like New. Hardcover. Binding tight. Pages clean. No missing pages. See photos.

85 characters

Fast grading rules

  • Like New: clean, tight, unmarked, jacket intact.
  • Very Good: light wear or foxing, no notes or highlighting.
  • Good: visible wear or limited pencil notes; all pages present.
  • Acceptable: obvious wear or minor water damage; text still readable.

Marketplace rules: Amazon·eBay

Marketplace rules

How Amazon and eBay grade used books

The same copy can be Good on Amazon and Acceptable on eBay. The biggest splits are highlighting, a missing dust jacket and remainder marks. Read both columns before choosing where to list.

GradeAmazon book ruleseBay book rules
Like NewMinor cosmetic defects allowed; dust jacket intact; pages clean and unmarked.Looks new but read; no visible cover wear; dust jacket included; no creases, tears or writing.
Very GoodMinor cosmetic defects; dust jacket or box set may be missing; remainder marks noted.No obvious cover damage; dust jacket included for hardcovers; no notes or highlighting.
GoodAll pages and cover intact; spine wear; limited notes, highlighting or library labels allowed.Minimal cover damage; dust jacket may be missing; minimal pencil underlining, no highlighting.
AcceptableAll pages and cover intact; may have notes, highlighting or minor water damage if readable.Obvious wear; binding intact; writing or highlighting possible but text must remain legible.

Summarised from Amazon's book condition guidelines and eBay's Books & Magazines condition definitions. The generator grades boundary flaws down one level to reduce return risk.

The checklist

What actually moves a book grade

Check the book in this order. The spine and pages decide most of the grade; the jacket and extras are the most commonly forgotten disclosures.

Spine

A tight, square spine supports a higher grade. A light reading crease caps most books at Very Good; a heavy crease, lean or cracked hinge drops it further.

Cover

Corner rub, edge wear and scuffs are the difference between Like New and Very Good. Tears, holes and heavy wear are Acceptable territory.

Pages

Toning and foxing are cosmetic but still grade down. Creased pages cap at Good; water staining caps at Acceptable when the text is readable.

Markings

Pencil underlining is allowed in eBay Good but not Very Good. Highlighting or ink drops eBay to Acceptable while Amazon can still allow Good.

Dust jacket

Hardcovers need the jacket for Like New and Very Good on eBay. Amazon allows a missing jacket at Very Good; eBay caps it at Good.

Ex-library

Stamps, stickers and pockets are disclosable flaws. Both marketplaces usually land at Good unless the wear is heavier.

Remainder marks

A mark on the page edges is visible wear. Amazon permits it in Like New when disclosed; this tool grades down to Very Good for safer resale.

Odor and damage

Smoke odor caps at Acceptable. Mildew, heavy water damage or missing pages mean do not list.

Resale traps

Foxing, remainder marks and “looks fine” flaws

Foxing is the brown spotting that appears on old paper. It is cosmetic, but it is visible wear. A foxed book is not Like New, even when the binding is tight and there are no notes.

Remainder marks are the small lines or dots on page edges from publisher overstock. Amazon's guidelines allow them in Like New when disclosed; most buyers still treat them as wear. This tool grades them at Very Good for safer resale.

Ex-library copies need every stamp, sticker, pocket and removed-pocket ghost disclosed. A clean-looking library discard can still be Good, but it is not Very Good.

Dust jacket wear is the biggest Amazon-versus-eBay split. Amazon allows a missing jacket at Very Good; eBay drops a hardcover without its jacket to Good.

Do not list if…

  • Pages are missing or the text is incomplete.
  • The book smells of mildew or mustiness.
  • Water damage has warped the pages or made them unreadable.
  • The binding is broken and pages are falling out.
  • The cover or jacket hides damage that is not photographed.

A return costs more than the difference between Good and Acceptable. When a flaw is borderline, grade down and disclose.

Copy-ready output

What a good flaw disclosure looks like

A useful description does three jobs: it names the grade, lists every visible flaw, and states the positives without hiding the negatives. The generator builds the same structure from your checklist.

Lead with the marketplace grade and format.

List flaws as short bullets, not a vague paragraph.

Say what is still good: binding, pages, completeness.

Disclose ex-library marks, remainder marks and missing inserts.

Ask the buyer to review the photos before purchase.

Example eBay description

The Old Man and the Sea by Ernest Hemingway

Condition: Good (eBay)
Format: Hardcover · Dust jacket included, light wear

Flaws and wear:
• Light edge and corner wear to the cover.
• Light reading crease to the spine.
• Remainder mark on the bottom page edge.
• Pages show light toning; no writing or highlighting.

Binding is tight and square. Pages are clean of writing and highlighting. No missing pages.

Please review the photos and condition notes before purchase. Sold as described.

Used book condition FAQ

The grading questions that cause the most returns and the clearest answers.

How do I grade a used book for Amazon or eBay?

Check the spine, cover, page edges, markings, dust jacket, ex-library marks, remainder marks and odor. Start at Like New only if the book is clean, tight and unmarked with an intact jacket. Any visible wear, note, highlighting, library mark, remainder mark or missing jacket drops the grade. The tool applies Amazon and eBay rules separately because they do not grade the same flaws the same way.

What is the difference between Good and Acceptable for used books?

Good is a clean, complete reading copy with minor wear and no missing pages. Acceptable is a worn but complete copy that may have obvious cover wear, heavier creasing, writing, highlighting or minor water staining as long as the text is still readable. Missing pages, mildew or heavy water damage mean do not list.

Does a remainder mark lower the grade?

Yes in practice. Amazon's book guidelines allow a remainder mark in Used - Like New when it is disclosed, but buyers often treat it as wear. This tool grades remainder marks down to Very Good for safer resale. eBay treats the mark as visible wear, so Very Good is the realistic ceiling.

How does foxing affect a book grade?

Foxing is the brown spotting that appears on older paper. It is cosmetic and does not affect readability, but it is visible wear. This tool caps foxed books at Very Good on both Amazon and eBay. Heavy foxing, musty odor or stained pages can push the copy lower.

Can I sell a former library book on Amazon or eBay?

Yes, if you disclose the stamps, stickers, pocket or remainder marks. Ex-library copies usually grade at Good unless the wear is heavier. Never describe an ex-library copy as Like New, and check for removed pocket residue or damaged endpapers.

What if the dust jacket is missing?

On eBay, Very Good and Like New require the dust jacket for hardcovers, so a missing jacket caps the grade at Good. Amazon allows a missing dust jacket at Very Good. The tool shows both grades so you can choose the marketplace before listing.

Does highlighting make a book Acceptable?

On eBay, Good allows minimal pencil underlining but not highlighting or writing in the margins, so highlighting usually means Acceptable. Amazon's Good grade allows limited notes and highlighting, so the same copy can be Good on Amazon and Acceptable on eBay.

Can I sell a book with water damage?

Only if the damage is minor, the text is readable and you disclose it. Amazon's Acceptable grade allows limited notes, highlighting or minor water damage if readable. eBay Acceptable also requires the text to remain legible. Heavy water damage, warping, mildew or loose pages mean do not list.

What should a book condition description include?

Include the marketplace grade, format, dust jacket status, spine and cover wear, page condition, any writing or highlighting, ex-library or remainder marks, missing inserts and odor. Keep it factual and specific. The generator turns the checklist into a copy-ready Amazon condition note and eBay description.

Is a 9-digit number on a book a date code?

No. A number such as 00501-0000 is a style or product code, not a condition grade or publication date. For condition grading, use the physical checklist: spine, cover, pages, markings, jacket and odor.

Grade with the buyer in mind

A conservative grade plus a precise flaw list beats an optimistic grade and a surprise. Buyers rarely dispute a book that looks exactly like the description.

Works with media flips

Use the output for Amazon condition notes, eBay descriptions, Facebook Marketplace listings and your own inventory notes. The grade logic is marketplace-specific, the flaw list is not.

Sources and date

Last reviewed November 2026

Condition definitions are summarised from Amazon Seller Central's book condition guidelines and eBay's Books & Magazines condition definitions. Marketplace rules can change; confirm high-value or borderline listings in the seller dashboard.

This tool is a grading aid, not a guarantee that a marketplace will accept a listing. Photograph every disclosed flaw and keep the listing consistent with the physical copy.

ResellCompass

The reseller workbench

The next flip starts with better math.

34 free calculators for fees, shipping, sourcing, listing research and client payouts. No account or spreadsheet needed.