Skip to content
Accept, counter or decline

Offer profit calculator

A Poshmark offer or eBay Best Offer is a margin decision, not a price decision. Enter the list price, the buyer's offer and your costs to see exactly what you keep after commission, processing and any seller-paid shipping discount.

Your floor is the lowest price that still clears your minimum profit. When an offer falls below it, the calculator returns the counter price that gets you back above the line.

How to use this calculator

Three steps to a reliable answer.

Quick guide
  1. 1Enter the list price, the buyer's offer, your item cost and shipping cost.
  2. 2Set buyer-paid shipping and any seller-paid shipping subsidy.
  3. 3Read the offer profit, gap to your floor and the suggested counter before accepting.

The floor is the lowest offer that still clears the profit you require after fees, shipping and cost. A counter at or above the floor protects the margin without guessing.

Offer inputs

Recalculates as you type.

Marketplace

Facebook Marketplace offers are informal and usually local. A $0 shipping cost models a no-fee local pickup.

$
$
Discount
$
$

Adds shipping to the order total and to shipping-based fees.

Cuts what the buyer pays for shipping; the difference comes out of your payout.

$

The least profit you will accept on this item.

Advanced fees
%

Applies to eBay promoted listings only.

Adds 12% on Etsy when an offsite ad converts.

Clear to accept

The offer clears your $10.00 floor by $17.45.

25.0% off

Profit

$27.45

Net payout

$48.45

Total fees

$2.55

Margin

61.0%

At your $60.00 list price you would keep $41.70. This offer changes profit by −$14.25.

Your floor

$26.64

Lowest price for $10.00 profit

Suggested counter

$27.00

Rounded up to the next dollar

Shipping you absorb

$0.00

Buyer pays $6.00

Fee breakdown
Offer price$45.00
Buyer-paid shipping$6.00
Order total$51.00
Platform fee-$2.55
Total fees-$2.55
Shipping label-$6.00
Item cost-$15.00
Profit$27.45

Fees use the 2026.2 US schedule. Offers are rounded to the cent.

Poshmark offer discount calculator

Poshmark offers to likers usually come with a seller-paid shipping discount, and a 20% commission applies to the item price. A 25% price cut plus a shipping subsidy can cut your margin far deeper than the offer percentage suggests.

Model the offer, the shipping discount and the $2.95 flat fee under $15 in one place. If the offer is under your floor, use the counter suggestion instead of splitting the difference.

eBay Best Offer profit margin

eBay charges the same 13.6% final value fee on a Best Offer as on a Buy It Now sale, including shipping the buyer pays. Set auto-accept and auto-decline thresholds around your floor, not your list price.

Promoted listing rates stack on top of the final value fee. Add the promoted percentage in advanced fees to see the true margin on the offer.

How the counteroffer floor is calculated

One number to defend, so you can answer an offer in seconds.

01

Start from the buyer's offer

Shipping the buyer pays is added to the order total, so shipping-based fees are included.

02

Subtract every fee and cost

Commission, payment processing, the shipping label, item cost, promoted listings and any seller-paid shipping discount.

03

Solve for the floor

The calculator works backward from your minimum profit to the lowest price that clears it, then rounds the counter up to the dollar.

Next tool

Bundle profit calculator

Check whether buy 3 get 25% off beats three separate sales.

Packaging

Shipping & packaging math

Check DIM weight and USPS cubic tiers before the label.

Listing prep

Sizing, SKU & markdown tools

Convert vintage measurements and plan a fee-safe markdown ladder.

Compare

All six marketplace payouts

Rank eBay, Poshmark, Mercari, Depop, Etsy and Facebook by profit.

Offer profit FAQ

Poshmark offers, eBay Best Offers and how to defend a profit floor.

How do I calculate profit on a Poshmark offer?

Take the offer amount, subtract Poshmark's 20% commission (or the $2.95 flat fee under $15), then subtract any seller-paid shipping discount, your shipping label and your item cost. For example, a $50 offer with a $2.98 shipping discount, a $7.97 label and a $15 cost leaves about $17.05 profit. The offer calculator does this instantly and shows whether the offer clears your floor.

How much should I counter on Poshmark?

Counter at your floor — the lowest price that still clears the profit you need — instead of splitting the difference. If an offer leaves you $2 profit but your floor is $10, the calculator shows the exact counter price that gets you there. Round the counter up to the next dollar so there is room for a final concession.

How do I calculate profit on an eBay Best Offer?

eBay charges its final value fee on the offer plus shipping, plus $0.30 per order on most categories. Enter the list price and the offer, and the calculator applies the 13.6% final value fee, any promoted listing rate, the shipping label and your item cost. The result is the real profit margin on that Best Offer.

Does a seller-paid shipping discount reduce platform fees?

On eBay, Etsy and Mercari, fees are charged on the shipping the buyer pays, so discounting shipping also reduces the fee on shipping slightly. Poshmark's commission is based on the item price, while Depop's processing is charged on the full order including buyer-paid shipping, so a shipping discount affects each platform differently.

What is a good minimum profit per item for resellers?

Most part-time resellers use a fixed dollar floor, often $8 to $15 per item, rather than a percentage. A dollar floor protects low-cost items where a 20% margin is only a couple of dollars, and it makes counteroffers fast because there is one number to defend.

Can I accept an offer below my floor?

Sometimes, for dead stock or a bulk clearance where cash flow matters more than margin. The calculator makes the trade-off visible: it shows the exact profit at the offer and how far below your floor it is, so accepting is a deliberate decision rather than a surprise.

ResellCompass estimates fees from published 2026 US fee schedules. Actual charges vary by category, seller level, taxes, promotions and order details. Always confirm in your seller dashboard. Not affiliated with eBay, Poshmark, Mercari, Depop, Etsy or Meta.

ResellCompass

The reseller workbench

The next flip starts with better math.

34 free calculators for fees, shipping, sourcing, listing research and client payouts. No account or spreadsheet needed.